Critical Thinking Speaking Prompts That Increase Student Engagement

in The English Teacher's Toolkit

If your students freeze when you ask an open-ended question, make the first step easier: give them two choices. This or That task cards help students start talking quickly because they only need to choose one option and explain their reason. This simple structure leads to stronger ESL speaking practice, better reasoning, and more complete answers.

Get the resource here: This or That Task Cards on Hot Chocolate Teachables or This or That Speaking Task Cards on TPT.

This or That speaking task cards for ESL discussion and decision-making practice — Use these This or That cards to build discussion skills, decision-making language, and speaking confidence.

Why This or That Questions Get Students Talking

This or That questions work because they remove the hardest part of speaking: figuring out where to begin. When students see two clear options, they can make a quick choice and then build their answer with reasons, examples, and follow-up questions.

These cards are especially useful for:

Reluctant speakers who need a clear starting point
Mixed-level ESL classes where students need flexible output options
Critical thinking activities with more than one possible answer
Low-prep speaking centers you can reuse all year

What Are This or That Speaking Task Cards?

This or That task cards are discussion cards that present a short real-life situation and two possible choices. Students choose Option A or Option B, then explain why their choice makes sense.

They feel simple, but they help students practice important language for opinions, decision-making, problem-solving, and classroom discussion.

This or That task cards with decision-making speaking prompts for classroom discussion — Students choose between two options, explain their thinking, and compare answers with classmates.

How These Cards Build Critical Thinking

Decision-making activities help students do more than share opinions. They learn to compare options, explain consequences, and defend their thinking. This makes the cards ideal for critical thinking speaking activities and ESL discussion practice.

Students practice:

Reasoning: explaining why one choice is better
Problem-solving: thinking through realistic situations
Perspective-taking: listening to a different opinion
Discussion language: agreeing, disagreeing, and asking follow-up questions

How to Use the Cards with ESL Students

These cards are perfect for ESL because students can begin with a simple answer and expand from there. The same card can work for beginners, developing speakers, and more advanced learners.

Easy differentiation

Beginner: “I choose A because ___.”
Developing: Add one example: “For example, ___.”
Advanced: Add a counterpoint: “However, ___.”

Quick fixes for common speaking problems

One-word answers: require “choice + because.”
Weak reasons: give students a reason bank: safer, faster, cheaper, easier, fairer, more fun.
Dominant speakers: use timed turns so every student speaks.

This or That ESL discussion cards for mixed-level speaking practice — Use the same prompt with different speaking expectations for mixed-level classes.

Speaking Center Ideas

Partner Discussion

One student reads the card.
Both students choose A or B.
Each student gives one reason.
Partners ask one follow-up question.

Debate Corners

Label one side of the room A and the other side B. Students move to their chosen side and explain their thinking to someone nearby.

Quick Speaking Check

Have students complete three cards and give a short response for each one: choice, reason, and follow-up question.

Writing Extensions

These cards also work well as short opinion writing prompts. Speaking first helps students organize their ideas before they write.

Opinion paragraph: “I choose ___ because ___.”
Pros and cons list: write two benefits and one drawback.
Advice response: explain the best choice to a friend.
Partner comparison: summarize a partner’s answer and respond.

Sentence Starters for Better Discussion

Choice and reason

I would choose ___ because ___.
The better option is ___ because ___.
I think ___ makes more sense because ___.

Examples and evidence

For example, ___.
In my opinion, ___.
This is important because ___.

Agreeing and disagreeing

I agree because ___.
I see your point, but ___.
Another idea is ___.

What’s Included

This set includes 48 real-life decision-making discussion cards designed for speaking practice, critical thinking, and opinion sharing.

48 This or That speaking cards
Real-life scenarios with two choices
Great for partners, small groups, centers, warm-ups, and sub plans
Print-and-go format for easy prep and reuse

This or That discussion questions for students with opinion speaking prompts — Low-prep speaking prompts that help students explain opinions and compare choices.

Easy Classroom Uses

Bell ringer: project one card for quick partner talk.
Speaking center: students complete three cards with sentence frames.
Whole-class debate: students move to A or B and explain why.
Early finishers: students record a 60-second response.
Writing follow-up: students write a short opinion paragraph.
Formative check: listen for choice, reason, and follow-up question.

Success looks like this: students choose an option, give a clear reason, and respond to a partner respectfully.

Shop the This or That Speaking Task Cards

More Blog Posts You Might Like

Created by Hot Chocolate Teachables

Best Phonics Games for Teaching Beginning Blends (L, R & S Blends)

Beginning blends can be challenging for early readers because students have to hear and say two consonant sounds together without adding an extra syllable. A child may know individual letter sounds but still hesitate when reading words like frog, clap, or stop. The best way to build confidence is through short, repeated practice that feels active and engaging. Instead of relying only on worksheets, students benefit from hands-on phonics games that give them many chances to read blend words aloud. In this post, you’ll find a simple way to introduce beginning blends and use phonics card games to help students practice S blends, L blends, and R blends in a fun, repeatable way. What Are Beginning Blends? Beginning blends are two consonants that appear together at the start of a word. Each consonant keeps its own sound, but the sounds are blended smoothly together. Examples include: BR in brush CL in clap ST in star GR in green Blends are different from digraphs. With a blend, both sounds are heard. With a digraph, two letters work together to make one new sound. Why Beginning Blends Can Be Difficult Students often struggle with beginning blends because they have to process two consonant sounds quickly. Some students leave out one sound, add an extra vowel, or guess the word before reading it carefully. Common examples include: frog becomes fog slide becomes side stop becomes top That’s why repeated oral reading practice is so important. Students need to hear the blend, say the blend, read the word, and use the pattern again and again. Step 1: Teach One Blend Family at a Time Instead of introducing every blend at once, start with one blend family. This keeps the lesson focused and helps students notice patterns more easily. S blends L blends R blends Once students are comfortable with one group, you can mix blend families together for review. Step 2: Model the Blend Clearly When teaching a new blend, say the sounds slowly at first, then blend them together smoothly. Be careful not to add an extra vowel sound between the consonants. For example: /s/ + /t/ = /st/ Then connect the blend to real words: star stop stick Step 3: Practice Blend Words Before Reading Longer Text Before students read blends in books or passages, they need focused practice with individual words. This helps them build decoding speed and automaticity. Useful practice formats include: phonics card games task cards matching games partner practice literacy centers Step 4: Add Hands-On Phonics Games Phonics games are a great way to give students repeated practice without making the lesson feel repetitive. UNO-style card games work especially well because students already understand the basic idea of matching cards by color or number. To make the game phonics-focused, students read the blend word aloud before placing a card. This turns every turn into meaningful decoding practice. S Blends Phonics Card Game The S Blends UNO-Style Card Game helps students practice beginning blend words with SC, SK, SM, SN, SP, ST, and SW. Students match by color or number while reading each word aloud. This gives them repeated exposure to common S blend patterns in a fun and familiar format. You can also find this resource on Teachers Pay Teachers. L Blends Phonics Card Game The L Blends Phonics Card Game gives students practice with BL, CL, FL, GL, PL, and SL. This game is helpful for students who need more practice blending two consonant sounds smoothly before reading the rest of the word. You can also find this resource on Teachers Pay Teachers. R Blends Phonics Card Game The R Blends Phonics Card Game focuses on BR, CR, DR, FR, GR, PR, and TR. This game works well in small groups and intervention because students get repeated oral reading practice with words that often cause blending errors. You can also find this resource on Teachers Pay Teachers. Why Phonics Games Help Beginning Blends Stick Game-based phonics practice gives students the repetition they need while keeping motivation high. Students often read more words during a game than they would during a worksheet, which means more decoding practice in less time. Hands-on phonics games also help students: practice blend words repeatedly read aloud in a low-pressure format build decoding fluency stay engaged during phonics centers review without feeling like they are doing extra work Easy Ways to Use Beginning Blend Games Literacy Centers Use the games after you have introduced the blend pattern. Students can play independently or with partners. Small Groups Use the cards for targeted decoding practice and quick teacher feedback. Intervention Have students read each word aloud before playing a card. Listen for dropped sounds or added vowels. Early Finishers Keep a deck in an early finisher bin for meaningful phonics review. ESL and EFL Practice The oral reading routine supports both pronunciation and decoding skills. Frequently Asked Questions About Beginning Blends What are beginning blends? Beginning blends are two consonants at the start of a word where both sounds are still heard, such as br in brush or st in star. What is the difference between blends and digraphs? In blends, both consonant sounds are heard. In digraphs, two letters work together to make one new sound, such as sh or ch. Which beginning blends should I teach first? Many teachers introduce S blends, L blends, and R blends as separate groups before mixing them together for review. Can these games be used with ESL students? Yes. These games are useful for ESL and EFL learners because they combine decoding, pronunciation, and repeated oral reading. How long should students practice beginning blends? Short, consistent practice is usually best. Ten to fifteen minutes of focused practice several times a week can be more effective than one long lesson. Final Thoughts Beginning blends become easier when students get repeated practice in a format that feels fun and manageable. Hands-on phonics games help students read blend words again and again while building confidence, fluency, and accuracy. If you need simple beginning blends activities for literacy centers, small groups, intervention, or phonics review, these S blends, L blends, and R blends card games are an easy way to make practice more engaging. Related Resources S Blends UNO-Style Card Game L Blends Phonics Card Game R Blends Phonics Card Game More Blog Posts You Might Like 5 ESL Speaking Activities for Student Engagement Teacher Toolkit Unlimited ESL Resources Easy ESL Activities for Busy Teachers

Learn more

How to Teach R Blends Using Engaging Phonics Task Cards

If your students can read CVC words but slow down when words begin with R blends, they need more than another worksheet. They need quick, repeated decoding practice with clear visuals and immediate feedback. These R blends task cards and R blends clip cards help students hear the blend, say both sounds smoothly, and recognize beginning R blend patterns in print. Get the resource here: R Blends Phonics Task Cards on Hot Chocolate Teachables or R Blends Task Cards on TPT. Use these R blends task cards for phonics centers, small groups, intervention, and early finishers. What Are R Blends? R blends are consonant blends where the second sound is /r/. Students need to say both consonant sounds clearly and blend them into the rest of the word. Common R blend words include: br: brush, brick, brown cr: crab, crown, crash dr: drum, drop, drive fr: frog, free, fruit gr: green, grapes, grin pr: press, prize, proud tr: tree, train, truck For many first graders, the challenge is not knowing the letters. The challenge is blending the sounds smoothly without adding an extra vowel or skipping one of the sounds. Why Beginning R Blends Need Extra Practice Students usually need repeated, focused practice before beginning R blends become automatic. A quick mini-lesson is a good start, but most students need to read, hear, sort, and say the blends many times. Common mistakes to watch for Adding an extra vowel: saying “tuh-rain” instead of “train.” Dropping the first sound: reading “rain” instead of “brain.” Guessing from pictures: choosing the image without reading the word. A simple fix is to have students tap the first two letters, say the blend quickly, and then read the whole word. For example: /tr/ + ain = train. R Blends to Teach: BR, CR, DR, FR, GR, PR, and TR This resource focuses on BR, CR, DR, FR, GR, PR, and TR. Teaching these blends together helps students notice the pattern: two consonants, two sounds, then the vowel. Before centers or small groups, try a 60-second warm-up: Say the blend quickly: /br/. Students repeat without adding extra vowel sounds. Say a word: brush. Repeat with cr, dr, fr, gr, pr, tr. Hands-On Ways to Practice R Blends The easiest way to teach R blends activities is to keep the target blends the same but rotate the activity format. This gives students repeated practice without making phonics feel repetitive. Day 1: clip cards for blend recognition Day 2: word-to-picture matching Day 3: odd one out cards Day 4: mixed review in centers Day 5: quick oral reading check Using R Blends Task Cards in Phonics Centers R blends task cards work well in phonics centers because the format is predictable. Students can focus on decoding instead of learning new directions every day. Task cards give students repeated practice with beginning R blends in a simple center format. Center setup Store cards in a labeled bin or task card box. Add clothespins for clip cards. Include a recording sheet if you want accountability. Have students read two cards aloud before moving on. Small Group Ideas for R Blends Practice Small groups are ideal for R blends reading intervention because you can hear exactly where students are struggling and correct errors right away. Simple 10-minute routine Warm up: practice br, cr, dr, fr, gr, pr, tr aloud. Read: students read 6–8 cards aloud. Build: students write or build one R blend word. Check: students read one sentence with an R blend word. Example: If a student says “fuh-rog,” model the blend quickly: /fr/. Then have them read: /fr/ + og = frog. How to Use R Blends Clip Cards R blends clip cards are perfect for students who need quick, hands-on practice without a lot of writing. Students read the word or picture prompt, identify the beginning blend, and clip the correct answer. Clip cards make R blends practice hands-on and easy to use in centers. Differentiation ideas Support: students whisper-read the word to a partner before clipping. Challenge: students use the word in a complete sentence after clipping. Word-to-Picture Matching for R Blend Words Word-to-picture matching helps students connect decoding with meaning. Instead of only identifying the blend, students read the full word and match it to the correct image. To reduce guessing, use a simple “blend tap” routine. Students tap the first two letters, say the blend, and then read the word before choosing the picture. Odd One Out R Blends Practice Odd one out cards help students slow down and compare sounds carefully. Students decide which word or picture does not belong, often because it begins with a different R blend. Teacher tip: Have students explain their answer: “This one starts with gr. The others start with tr.” What’s Included in the R Blends Task Cards Resource This set is designed for repeated, hands-on R blends phonics practice in centers, small groups, and intervention. Printable R blends task cards for BR, CR, DR, FR, GR, PR, TR R blends clip cards Word-to-picture matching cards Odd one out phonics task cards Student recording sheets Answer keys Color and black-and-white options Box labels for organization Use the included box labels to keep your R blends task cards organized and ready to reuse. Where to Use These R Blends Activities Phonics centers: independent beginning blends practice Small groups: targeted decoding with teacher support Intervention: extra practice for students who need slower blending work Morning tubs: hands-on word work Early finishers: meaningful phonics review Sub plans: predictable tasks with answer keys Success looks like this: students can identify the beginning R blend, say both consonant sounds smoothly, and read the full word accurately. Shop the R Blends Task Cards R Blends Phonics Task Cards on Hot Chocolate Teachables R Blends Task Cards on Teachers Pay Teachers More Blog Posts You Might Like Hands-on L blends practice for first grade phonics centers and small groups S blends phonics games with a no-prep routine for bingo, clip cards, and card games Teacher Toolkit Membership: unlimited ESL resources for busy teachers Created by Hot Chocolate Teachables

Learn more

How Prediction Activities Strengthen Reading Comprehension and Speaking Skills

If your students struggle to come up with ideas during speaking or writing time, give them a story choice to start with. These Choose What Happens Next task cards give students a short scenario, three possible directions, and a clear reason to talk. Students choose option A, B, or C, explain their thinking, and continue the story in their own words. This format is perfect for ESL speaking practice, creative writing centers, mixed-level classes, and students who need support with prediction, inferencing, and storytelling. Get the resource here: Choose What Happens Next Task Cards on Hot Chocolate Teachables or Choose What Happens Next Task Cards on TPT. Use these storytelling task cards to build prediction skills, speaking confidence, and creative thinking. Why Prediction Activities Work So Well Prediction is not just guessing. When students predict what happens next, they look for clues, think about cause and effect, and explain why one outcome makes sense. That makes this a strong activity for reading comprehension, speaking, and writing. These prediction task cards help students practice: Inferencing: using clues from the scenario Critical thinking: choosing the most logical next step Storytelling: continuing a story with a clear sequence Speaking fluency: explaining ideas in complete sentences Creative writing: turning a prompt into an original ending What Are Choose What Happens Next Task Cards? Choose What Happens Next task cards are open-ended storytelling cards. Each card includes a short story situation and three choices for what could happen next. Students pick one option and then explain or write what happens after that. They feel a little like choose your own adventure task cards, but they are designed for classroom use. Students do not have to create a story from scratch. They begin with a clear situation, make a choice, and continue from there. Students read the scenario, choose A, B, or C, and continue the story. How the Activity Works The routine is simple enough for students to learn quickly and reuse all year. Time needed: 10–20 minutes for speaking or 20–35 minutes for writing Prep: print, cut, and laminate if desired Materials: task cards, timer, notebook or recording sheet Read the scenario. Choose what happens next: A, B, or C. Explain the choice using a sentence frame. Continue the story with a few spoken or written sentences. Share and compare different endings. Helpful sentence frames I choose ___ because ___. I think ___ will happen next because ___. First ___, then ___, and finally ___. Skills Students Practice These cards may feel like a game, but they target important speaking, reading, and writing skills. Speaking and listening Explaining choices clearly Using complete sentences Taking turns in pairs or groups Asking follow-up questions Reading comprehension Making predictions Using clues from the scenario Understanding cause and effect Thinking about character actions and consequences Writing Writing story endings Using sequencing words Adding details Creating a clear beginning, middle, and ending Ways to Use the Cards for Speaking Practice These speaking task cards work well because students make a simple choice first. That small step lowers the pressure and gives them something concrete to explain. Partner Talk Partner A reads the card. Partner B chooses A, B, or C. Partner B explains the choice. Partner A adds the next sentence in the story. Small-Group Story Circle One student reads the scenario. Everyone votes on what should happen next. Then each student adds one sentence to continue the story. Quick Speaking Challenge Students choose a card and speak for 30–60 seconds. This is a great warm-up, bell ringer, or informal fluency check. Use the cards for partner speaking, small-group discussion, or quick fluency practice. Ways to Use the Cards for Writing These cards also make excellent creative writing prompts. Since students already have a scenario and three choices, they spend less time staring at a blank page and more time developing their ideas. Short story ending Students choose one card, select A/B/C, and write 6–10 sentences to continue the story. Expand the moment Students choose one sentence from their story and add more detail using feelings, actions, and description. Dialogue practice Students turn the ending into a short conversation between characters. This is a helpful way to practice quotation marks and speech verbs. How to Use These Cards with ESL and Mixed-Level Classes These ESL storytelling task cards are easy to differentiate because all students can use the same card while producing different levels of language. Beginners: choose A/B/C and complete one sentence frame. Developing students: explain their choice and add 2–3 story sentences. Advanced students: add a twist, a problem, or a surprise ending. Teacher tip: Require “choice + reason + next sentence.” This keeps students from stopping after they choose an answer and helps build stronger speaking output. What’s Included This task card set includes everything you need for low-prep prediction, storytelling, and speaking practice. 48 open-ended storytelling task cards Original story scenarios A/B/C choices on each card Print-and-go format Great for speaking, writing, discussion, and centers Print once and reuse for speaking centers, writing prompts, early finishers, and sub plans. Easy Classroom Ideas Bell ringer: project one card and have students discuss in pairs. Speaking center: students complete three cards with a partner. Writing center: students choose one card and write a full story ending. Early finishers: students record a short spoken story. Small group: use the cards to build complete sentence responses. Sub plans: leave cards with a simple speaking or writing routine. Success looks like this: students can make a prediction, give a reason, and continue the story with a clear sequence. Shop the Choose What Happens Next Task Cards Choose What Happens Next Task Cards on Hot Chocolate Teachables Choose What Happens Next Task Cards on Teachers Pay Teachers More Blog Posts You Might Like Five ESL speaking activities that actually get students talking Low-prep ESL speaking games for the first week of school Teacher Toolkit Membership: unlimited ESL resources for busy teachers Created by Hot Chocolate Teachables

Learn more

Critical Thinking Speaking Prompts That Increase Student Engagement

Why This or That Questions Get Students Talking

What Are This or That Speaking Task Cards?

How These Cards Build Critical Thinking